Відео

The funny thing about this is that the people who oppose this argument are the same ones who most agree with it on the closely related question of the reliability of our sense perceptions.

😂beautiful

😂beautiful

IDIOT.

I love this lady, she is an exceptional human being. God bless the beautiful and unique woman named Jane Goodall.

DIABOL v rúchu kňaza,chudáci bratia česi.

Congratulations Dr Pumla!🎉🎉🎉🎉

This is complete nonsense argument. Our faculties are not entirely reliable, but collectively, they become increasingly and significantly more reliable. Also, aren't we using the exact same faculties to presume the existence of gods? Which is exactly how deities developed across many human cultures. Even Christian divine communication has to be delievered to and received by our individual and collective faculties. Simply put, I can be more sure of the existence of my hand (e.g. I can show it to others, I can touch others, others can tell me it exists) than I am of any gods because recognition of my hands is a lot more fundamental than my ability to discern the existence of gods.

I have a hard time understanding how the argument manages to escape complete skepticism, since the argument itself is produced by our natural cognitive faculties. It surely and legitimately reminds us that we are faillible, but given the fact that humans seems to be able to adopt plausible beliefs which are totally unadaptative, doesn't seem weird to then reject naturalism and adopt a theistic worldview on the basis of pure faith?

I would love to hear the stories, but i hate crying . Enjoyed the video , the strength of the spirit in the light . BEAUTIFUL.. THANK YOU.

The crimes of apartheid, the murders, the maiming and cruelty towards the Black people of South Africa by the white classes that created trauma to setting aside the Native Africans. A young Black girl stole a purse from an English imagrant daughter of a newly imagrant family, The police illegally bound the young girls left arm with cageing wire until it tore through her flesh. The English couple were horrified at this treatment of the young Black teenager without any legal charge or trial. The Husband and Father of the two white woman tried to have the criminal charges dropped, but the white police refused and took the young girl away. Meanwhile he contacted his boss who required his expertise on oil cracker in Johannesburg to try and get the poor girl released and treated for her greivous injury. the whole family left South Africa within the year, they moved to Scotland where I heard the whole story from them, But at the time I managed to land a job with an MoD company, despite a personal life-long Paraplegic illness I walked on two leg braces in a workshop where my work was seen as satisfactory. However there was an English man working there who hated me because I counted a young Black girl a good friend amongst many as I was older then, The English man also hated this young Black girl as she was tiny, and had nobody to protect her. my friends and I took on the job of protecting her, he was afraid of me and after a fight in the carpark of the factory unit I had a steel bar up my sleave and was using it to protect myself, A third party of higher rank stepped in and threw down the bully. both the bully and I were taken into the office and I was let go, but the bully said that he was quitting this job anyway, to move to South Africa. A man who hated cripples and Black people so much aught never to be given a visa to enter South Africa, than. Thank God that Apartied was brought to a justified end a mere number of months later. I felt sorry for that little Scots African girl, more so the black girl who was disfigured for life by the brutality of the SA police, who had no right to publicly torture her no matter what she did. I have never had anything but respect for the Black people in Scotland, but even I have noticed the wary looks that they are prone to give the whites around them. It is a disgrace the my fellow Scots can be seen to be prejudiced even in this day and age while the English nationalists are prejudiced against both Africans, Asians and the physically afflicted like me. for instance I fall a lot and often cannot get back up, but only on a few occasions do I lack for support Thanks Be to God, I have been helped by every race, color and creed. in this I am blessed.❤🙏🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

THERE IS A RAPTURE IN MY SOUL THERE IS A RAPTURE IN MY COUNTRY THER IS A RAPTURE IN MY AFRICA MAY GOD HEAL THE RAPTURE IN MY SOUL, MY COUNTRY, AND MY AFRICA AND BRING US CLOSER TO GOD.

❤

Just like that?

I'm living in a ⛺, which i installed near professor's 🏠, in desperate attempts to introduce my theory. In it strings vibrate in 287 dimensional time and manifold is curled into 266 brane-time-spaces.

Very interesting!

SUCH AN INSPIRATION to take active part in (1) the healing of both my own conscious and unconscious personal traumas and (2) the traumas that still affect South African interpersonal interactions, politics and perceived future prosperity and propagation of our country. Hopefully more people will become aware of the importance of the very necessary *Reparative Quest* our country needs to embark on. It started with the TRC, now we need something else. We have dealt with the immediate acknowledgement of traumas, but I feel we are struggling with consolidating those traumas and allowing ourselves to move forward while not forgetting the impact of the those traumas and need to consistently repair the wounded fabric of the South African tapestry.

♥

Congratulations Dr Pumla Gobodo. We are proud of you. God bless 🙏

Congratulations Doc

Absolutely amazing. The prize pales in worth when compared to her work. Thank you, Dr. Pumla Gobodo-Madikizela.

Huge congratulations to you, Prof Pumla! Your impact, compassion and wisdom is indelible, and this award is so well-deserved.

Congrats Dr Pumla, a well deserved price. Healing from traumatic experience like murder of loved one is never easy, but worthwhile

Wow! Congratulations to Dr. Pulma! So inspirational. Thanks for sharing these stories in such a cinematic way. I hope many of us or around the world can learn from her and use her work in our communities to transform how the oppression and trauma of white supremacy has left a deep wound in the fabric of our collective culture and individual lives. We look forward to learning more as this prize is sure to make her work more accessible all around the world.

I can't unhear Jane from Tarzan and it's wonderful. Jane Goodall has been a hero of mine since I was a kid.

That's why we conduct experiments. So our preconceived beliefs don't influence our conclusions

From a naturalistic evolutionist perspective, the existence of religious believes is the most outstanding evidence that holding false believes can be absolutely advantageous for survival.

Dayum she cud rap!!!!!

Doesn't this argument apply to any origin story? If we were designed then we could just be believing what we were designed to believe, not necessarily what's true. So we still have no reason to believe that our reasoning leads to truth.

The 50/50 argument is very fallacious. Every single moment of my conscious day is full of successful mental activity, every step, every blink, every judgement. To say this success is based on adaptive behavior and not thinking about reality and its consequences cannot imply that I am successful via dumb luck (50/50). That my (evolutionarily generated) brain doesn't fully cope with truth is irrelevant. My brain can't deal with the problem that the sun will go supernova in 100,000,000 years. My brain can cope with the mess of physics, chemistry, biology and sociology that is reality.

You are a great organization. Jessie Shrieves, Artist

Time is God, Timing is godliness

Bůh je bezcharakterní svině on je to zlo ma radost z utrpení lidí nenávidím ho.

Plantinga is the sort of philosopher that gives philosophy a bad name - maker of pointless word salads.

His arguments are verbal fluff spun as if neither he nor we have any understanding of how science works, which is just a specialized execution of rigorous observation and reason.

☸️only in the World True☸️ ✨🌍🪷Namo Buddha Namo Nama🏔️🕊️✨

It amazes me anyone takes this man seriously. What utter horse shit.

he's really a genius

❤❤❤

We are incredibly lucky to have her with us. 🙌🏼🌎

Is it possible that I can translate the subtitle into Chinese so that I can share this wonderful interview with more Asians for the purpose of education only?

Subhanallah, mashallah, May Allah continue to give you strength, health and the fight to continue Being the Leading Woman of East Africa.

Plantinga is right, we can’t rely on our ability to reason. That’s why we test our beliefs!

I am a naturalistic evolutionist, and I agree with Plantinga that evolution’s only “goal” is to produce behaviors fitted for survival. But I think having a more accurate view of reality than your competition is absolutely advantageous for survival. Plantinga seems to be claiming that it’s not. If you take two animals of the same species, both having behaviors that help them survive, but one has a slightly more accurate belief about the world, that one is definitely going to do better when circumstances require them to improvise or go “off script” from the learned behavior. The more granular your understanding of a system, the better you can troubleshoot when things go wrong. Plantinga’s point, though, is a good one! That’s why the scientific method is so important: we must test our beliefs. Reason without testing has lead us to strange places. Spicy section: this is a bit of a cheap shot on my part, but from where I’m sitting it really looks like religion emerged from exactly what Plantinga points out: false beliefs that produce behaviors that assist in survival. Also, this very argument seems to imply that Plantinga sees human reason as spiritually inspired, or something like that. I think the naturalistic perspective encourages a much more humble and, therefore, flexible mind.

❤

While this is a fascinating argument, I think it is somewhat blinsided by its own premises. If, as the argument states, the truth of naturalism and evolution entails that our cognitive faculties have low reliability, then shouldn't that make this argument itself unreliable? After all, if my cognitive faculty of reasoning is not a reliable indicator of truth, then why is this argument against naturalism reliable either? Rather, to accept this argument as valid, we would need to presuppose theism. In other words, this argument cannot work with the presupposition of naturalism (assuming evolution to be true, as done in argument). It needs theism to even work as a reliable argument. Conclusion: It's not naturalism that is self-defeating in light of the truth of evolution, it's this argument itself.

He’s the main reason I got into Christian Philosophy and of why I left it for Cultural Naturalism. Forever grateful. And I still respect him. Of course, when I read his lovely trilogy on warrant - including of course Warranted Christian Belief - I didn’t realize how much (and how brilliantly) he was adopting and adapting moves made before him by the likes of Quine. He was doing with Christianity what Quine was trying with naturalism. I believe he succeeded more than Quine. I believe Plantinga’s bravado, the confidence with which he spoke of things like the importance of Christian intellectual autonomy - say in his Advice To Christian Philosophers - did more to accomplish this Christian revolution in philosophy more than the arguments themselves. Unfortunately, Plantinga’s revolution in philosophy did not prevent the great dechurching or the disturbing waves of “deconstructions” on UA-cam. I say unfortunately of course not because I still agree with religious thought in the least. But the question of the relationship between the creation and transmission of ideas and large-scale social change is fascinating. And Plantinga is to me an instructive case. I suppose if we haven’t yet destroyed the planet we’ll have to check in another 100 years to see if his revolution will have some effects outside of professional philosophy. Meanwhile, those of us who are naturalists with humane, social, democratic commitments have lots of people coming out of religious belief. What to do?

01:06 Where is this place please?

👌👌👌

mind is like parachute once expanded will never get back to original shape but many use like pyara chooth